Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Search representations
Results for Sussex Butterfly Conservation search
New search New searchSupport
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy ENV8: Habitats & Species
Representation ID: 31760
Received: 15/11/2026
Respondent: Sussex Butterfly Conservation
Please see the attached representatioin for original formatting and full comments.
Sussex Butterfly Conservation supports the Local Plan’s biodiversity and environmental objectives but seeks stronger and more explicit measures for the protection and enhancement of butterflies, moths and their habitats. Habitat creation for butterflies is encouraged from the outset of the development design process, including provision of nectar sources, caterpillar food plants and other habitat features. Measures to minimise light pollution and protect moth populations are also proposed, including sensitive lighting design and the creation of dark areas free from artificial lighting. In addition, ecological assessments should consider butterfly and moth species, including priority species, using survey methodologies that adequately reflect seasonal variations and life cycles. Biodiversity enhancement, green infrastructure and ecological management measures should contribute to habitat creation, species conservation and wider nature recovery objectives.
Recommended policy wording is set out below:
a) “From the outset new development design should incorporate the creation of wildlife habitats to benefit butterfly species”
Consideration should be given to design which assists butterfly species at all stages of their lifecycle. Features could include:
a. Butterfly banks – for example “E” shaped
b. Nectar planting
c. Caterpillar food plants
d. Areas for overwintering adults/pupae
b) “New development and local green spaces should be designed and planned from the outset to minimize light pollution which could affect moths.”
Measures could include:
a. Considering appropriate lighting options including siting of light sources for new development
b. Creating Moon Meadows – green spaces free from light pollution. https://butterfly-conservation.org/join-the-dark-side
c. Plant moth-friendly plants alongside no-mow wild areas, in an area free from artificial light.
Please see the attached representatioin for original formatting.
Please find below the representation from Sussex Butterfly Conservation (BC) on the above consultation. Sussex BC also submitted a response to the Regulation 18 Local Plan consultation in March 2026.
Butterfly Conservation is the UK charity dedicated to saving butterflies, moths and our natural environment. We are a world-leading authority on the conservation of these beautiful and vital creatures. Butterfly Conservation's strength derives from its 32 Branches and over 40,000 members who help to deliver our key aims to:
• Halve the number of the UK’s threatened species of butterflies and moths
• Improve the condition of 100 of the most important landscapes for butterflies and moths
• Transform 100,000 wild spaces in the UK for people, butterflies and moths
Sussex BC is a member of the Sussex Local Nature Partnership and was involved in the preparation of the recently published East Sussex and Brighton & Hove Local Nature Recovery Strategy.
Butterflies are highly sensitive indicators of the health of the environment and play crucial roles in the food chain as well as being pollinators of plants. In addition, many butterflies and moths are designated in conservation terms as “Priority Species” being species most under threat because of their rarity and/or rate of decline.
In the UK, long-term trends show that 80% of butterfly species have decreased in abundance or distribution, or both since the 1970s. On average, UK butterflies have lost 6% of their total abundance at monitored sites and 42% of their distribution over the period 1976-2019.(1)
The total abundance of larger moths caught in the RIS light-trap network in Britain decreased by 33% over 50 years (1968–2017). Losses were greater in the southern half of Britain (39% decrease).(2)
Government policy (NPPF, August 2026) states that the objective of the policies in Chapter 19 “Conserving and enhancing the natural environment “is to influence the design and location of new development to help drive nature’s recovery and contribute to wider environmental outcomes, safeguarding our most important habitats, species and landscapes and recognising the centrality of natural capital to delivering sustainable growth. Many of the policies set out in Chapter 19 are relevant and pertinent to the protection and enhancement of habitat for butterflies and moths, including paragraphs N1 “Identifying environmental opportunities and safeguards”, N2 “Improving the natural environment” and N6 “Areas of particular importance for biodiversity and geodiversity.”
Sussex BC consider that these national policies should enable proper consideration within Local Plans of conservation of butterflies and moths and their habitats. In this context therefore, Sussex BC wish to make a positive contribution to the Rother Local Plan consultation to ensure that butterflies and moths are protected from development and that opportunities for increasing and enhancing their populations and habitats are secured. Sussex BC would welcome a dialogue with Rother DC on the matters raised below and would be happy to provide further advice on delivering the measures suggested as appropriate. Please find our detailed comments set out below:
1.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT:
The current consultation document includes the identification of a very large number of housing site allocations as well as those for employment and other uses. Some of the site allocations are located close or adjacent to designated wildlife sites, and to areas where the presence of butterflies has been recorded.
As a general principle, Sussex BC wish to see any development of the allocations take place in a way which protects and enhances butterflies and moths and their habitats, including the consideration of priority species, and the delivery of nature recovery.
In this respect Sussex BC notes the inclusion of policies in Chapter 7 on the Natural and Historic Environment and in particular LAN3 Trees, Woodlands and hedgerows, LAN4 Light Pollution and Dark Skies, ENV7 Biodiversity, ENV8 Habitats and species, ENV9 Local Nature Recovery Strategy, ENV10 Biodiversity Net Gain and HRE2 e. Conversion and Reuse of Historic Buildings -Biodiversity features.
These policies are very welcome and Sussex BC support their general aims but would request that they are extended to include measures to protect and enhance butterflies and moths and their habitats. We ask that the following measures relating to habitat creation for butterflies and to reducing light pollution to protect moths are incorporated into the Local Plan. Recommended policy wording is set out below:
a) “From the outset new development design should incorporate the creation of wildlife habitats to benefit butterfly species”
Consideration should be given to design which assists butterfly species at all stages of their lifecycle. Features could include:
a. Butterfly banks – for example “E” shaped
b. Nectar planting
c. Caterpillar food plants
d. Areas for overwintering adults/pupae
b) “New development and local green spaces should be designed and planned from the outset to minimize light pollution which could affect moths.”
Measures could include:
a. Considering appropriate lighting options including siting of light sources for new development
b. Creating Moon Meadows – green spaces free from light pollution. https://butterfly-conservation.org/join-the-dark-side
c. Plant moth-friendly plants alongside no-mow wild areas, in an area free from artificial light.
2. ECOLOGICAL ASSESSMENTS
We note that the requirements for development on many of the site allocations refer to areas for Biodiversity Net Gain, Landscape and Ecological Management Plans, multifunctional Green Infrastructure corridors, and ecological enhancements. We support these requirements and ask that they will include delivery of the measures above. Such improvements will need to be based on comprehensive ecological surveys and we would request that such assessment includes examination of the presence of butterfly and moth species. We would particularly note that to adequately establish which species are present, single surveys are likely to be inadequate, particularly as they will not capture the staggered emergence (as adults from pupae) periods of different species. In addition to visual surveying for adult butterflies, additional methodologies, such as UV searching for larvae and pupae, and winter egg surveying (for Brown Hairstreak eggs) may be appropriate.
While we do not have sufficient knowledge of the individual sites in the Rother Local Plan, we note that their general geographic location makes it a possibility that priority species Grizzled and Dingy Skipper, both very small, inconspicuous and easily overlooked species which emerge in the spring, could be present. White-letter Hairstreak, an Elm dependant (as it's larval food) species could also be present if Elm exists at specific sites, and Brown Hairstreak, similarly dependant on Blackthorn, are expanding eastwards throughout East Sussex and Kent and their colonisation of Rother District in the relatively near future is to be anticipated. The adult butterflies of both these Hairstreak priority species spend much of their time in the canopy of large tress, and can be difficult to locate, even when present at a site. We also note that White Admiral, a priority species, primarily of woodland, and dependant on Honeysuckle as larval food, are recorded adjacent to some allocation sites and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Ecological site surveys and assessments should therefore take account of the possible presence of all of these priority species.
3. PARTICULAR OPPORTUNITIES:
There are many allocations identified in the consultation document which are large both in area and scale of development. These sites would provide particularly good opportunities to incorporate butterfly habitat creation features as well as design to minimise light pollution for moths and we request that these principles are taken into account. In some cases there are sensitive habitats, especially hedgerows, at the edges and on the boundaries of the sites so particular care of these should be taken to protect and enhance these within the development design. We request that an ecological assessment of the site including for butterflies and moths takes place before the development is designed.
4. SITE ALLOCATIONS
a) Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly. We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
b) Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX28 Land at Northeye and adjoining land: some 384 dwellings; community uses which could include outdoor sports facilities including formal playing pitch(es).
BX25 Land at Barnhorn Green for Medical centre/light industrial which requires “a sensitive lighting strategy to avoid impacts on protected species and neighbouring amenity”.
(1) Fox R, Dennis EB, Purdy KM, Middlebrook I, Roy DB, Noble DG, Botham MS & Bourn NAD (2023) The State of the UK’s Butterflies 2022. Butterfly Conservation, Wareham, UK.
(2)Fox R, Dennis EB, Harrower CA, Blumgart D, Bell JR, Cook P, Davis AM, Evans-Hill LJ, Haynes F, Hill D, Isaac NJB, Parsons MS, Pocock MJO, Prescott T, Randle Z, Shortall CR, Tordoff GM, Tuson D & Bourn NAD (2021) The State of Britain’s Larger Moths 2021. Butterfly Conservation, Rothamsted Research and UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Wareham, Dorset, UK.
Attachments:
Object
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy BX23: Land south of Sandhurst Lane, Bexhill
Representation ID: 31761
Received: 15/11/2026
Respondent: Sussex Butterfly Conservation
Legally compliant? Not specified
Sound? Not specified
Please see full representation text below:
Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly.
We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
Please see the attached representatioin for original formatting.
Please find below the representation from Sussex Butterfly Conservation (BC) on the above consultation. Sussex BC also submitted a response to the Regulation 18 Local Plan consultation in March 2026.
Butterfly Conservation is the UK charity dedicated to saving butterflies, moths and our natural environment. We are a world-leading authority on the conservation of these beautiful and vital creatures. Butterfly Conservation's strength derives from its 32 Branches and over 40,000 members who help to deliver our key aims to:
• Halve the number of the UK’s threatened species of butterflies and moths
• Improve the condition of 100 of the most important landscapes for butterflies and moths
• Transform 100,000 wild spaces in the UK for people, butterflies and moths
Sussex BC is a member of the Sussex Local Nature Partnership and was involved in the preparation of the recently published East Sussex and Brighton & Hove Local Nature Recovery Strategy.
Butterflies are highly sensitive indicators of the health of the environment and play crucial roles in the food chain as well as being pollinators of plants. In addition, many butterflies and moths are designated in conservation terms as “Priority Species” being species most under threat because of their rarity and/or rate of decline.
In the UK, long-term trends show that 80% of butterfly species have decreased in abundance or distribution, or both since the 1970s. On average, UK butterflies have lost 6% of their total abundance at monitored sites and 42% of their distribution over the period 1976-2019.(1)
The total abundance of larger moths caught in the RIS light-trap network in Britain decreased by 33% over 50 years (1968–2017). Losses were greater in the southern half of Britain (39% decrease).(2)
Government policy (NPPF, August 2026) states that the objective of the policies in Chapter 19 “Conserving and enhancing the natural environment “is to influence the design and location of new development to help drive nature’s recovery and contribute to wider environmental outcomes, safeguarding our most important habitats, species and landscapes and recognising the centrality of natural capital to delivering sustainable growth. Many of the policies set out in Chapter 19 are relevant and pertinent to the protection and enhancement of habitat for butterflies and moths, including paragraphs N1 “Identifying environmental opportunities and safeguards”, N2 “Improving the natural environment” and N6 “Areas of particular importance for biodiversity and geodiversity.”
Sussex BC consider that these national policies should enable proper consideration within Local Plans of conservation of butterflies and moths and their habitats. In this context therefore, Sussex BC wish to make a positive contribution to the Rother Local Plan consultation to ensure that butterflies and moths are protected from development and that opportunities for increasing and enhancing their populations and habitats are secured. Sussex BC would welcome a dialogue with Rother DC on the matters raised below and would be happy to provide further advice on delivering the measures suggested as appropriate. Please find our detailed comments set out below:
1.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT:
The current consultation document includes the identification of a very large number of housing site allocations as well as those for employment and other uses. Some of the site allocations are located close or adjacent to designated wildlife sites, and to areas where the presence of butterflies has been recorded.
As a general principle, Sussex BC wish to see any development of the allocations take place in a way which protects and enhances butterflies and moths and their habitats, including the consideration of priority species, and the delivery of nature recovery.
In this respect Sussex BC notes the inclusion of policies in Chapter 7 on the Natural and Historic Environment and in particular LAN3 Trees, Woodlands and hedgerows, LAN4 Light Pollution and Dark Skies, ENV7 Biodiversity, ENV8 Habitats and species, ENV9 Local Nature Recovery Strategy, ENV10 Biodiversity Net Gain and HRE2 e. Conversion and Reuse of Historic Buildings -Biodiversity features.
These policies are very welcome and Sussex BC support their general aims but would request that they are extended to include measures to protect and enhance butterflies and moths and their habitats. We ask that the following measures relating to habitat creation for butterflies and to reducing light pollution to protect moths are incorporated into the Local Plan. Recommended policy wording is set out below:
a) “From the outset new development design should incorporate the creation of wildlife habitats to benefit butterfly species”
Consideration should be given to design which assists butterfly species at all stages of their lifecycle. Features could include:
a. Butterfly banks – for example “E” shaped
b. Nectar planting
c. Caterpillar food plants
d. Areas for overwintering adults/pupae
b) “New development and local green spaces should be designed and planned from the outset to minimize light pollution which could affect moths.”
Measures could include:
a. Considering appropriate lighting options including siting of light sources for new development
b. Creating Moon Meadows – green spaces free from light pollution. https://butterfly-conservation.org/join-the-dark-side
c. Plant moth-friendly plants alongside no-mow wild areas, in an area free from artificial light.
2. ECOLOGICAL ASSESSMENTS
We note that the requirements for development on many of the site allocations refer to areas for Biodiversity Net Gain, Landscape and Ecological Management Plans, multifunctional Green Infrastructure corridors, and ecological enhancements. We support these requirements and ask that they will include delivery of the measures above. Such improvements will need to be based on comprehensive ecological surveys and we would request that such assessment includes examination of the presence of butterfly and moth species. We would particularly note that to adequately establish which species are present, single surveys are likely to be inadequate, particularly as they will not capture the staggered emergence (as adults from pupae) periods of different species. In addition to visual surveying for adult butterflies, additional methodologies, such as UV searching for larvae and pupae, and winter egg surveying (for Brown Hairstreak eggs) may be appropriate.
While we do not have sufficient knowledge of the individual sites in the Rother Local Plan, we note that their general geographic location makes it a possibility that priority species Grizzled and Dingy Skipper, both very small, inconspicuous and easily overlooked species which emerge in the spring, could be present. White-letter Hairstreak, an Elm dependant (as it's larval food) species could also be present if Elm exists at specific sites, and Brown Hairstreak, similarly dependant on Blackthorn, are expanding eastwards throughout East Sussex and Kent and their colonisation of Rother District in the relatively near future is to be anticipated. The adult butterflies of both these Hairstreak priority species spend much of their time in the canopy of large tress, and can be difficult to locate, even when present at a site. We also note that White Admiral, a priority species, primarily of woodland, and dependant on Honeysuckle as larval food, are recorded adjacent to some allocation sites and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Ecological site surveys and assessments should therefore take account of the possible presence of all of these priority species.
3. PARTICULAR OPPORTUNITIES:
There are many allocations identified in the consultation document which are large both in area and scale of development. These sites would provide particularly good opportunities to incorporate butterfly habitat creation features as well as design to minimise light pollution for moths and we request that these principles are taken into account. In some cases there are sensitive habitats, especially hedgerows, at the edges and on the boundaries of the sites so particular care of these should be taken to protect and enhance these within the development design. We request that an ecological assessment of the site including for butterflies and moths takes place before the development is designed.
4. SITE ALLOCATIONS
a) Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly. We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
b) Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX28 Land at Northeye and adjoining land: some 384 dwellings; community uses which could include outdoor sports facilities including formal playing pitch(es).
BX25 Land at Barnhorn Green for Medical centre/light industrial which requires “a sensitive lighting strategy to avoid impacts on protected species and neighbouring amenity”.
(1) Fox R, Dennis EB, Purdy KM, Middlebrook I, Roy DB, Noble DG, Botham MS & Bourn NAD (2023) The State of the UK’s Butterflies 2022. Butterfly Conservation, Wareham, UK.
(2)Fox R, Dennis EB, Harrower CA, Blumgart D, Bell JR, Cook P, Davis AM, Evans-Hill LJ, Haynes F, Hill D, Isaac NJB, Parsons MS, Pocock MJO, Prescott T, Randle Z, Shortall CR, Tordoff GM, Tuson D & Bourn NAD (2021) The State of Britain’s Larger Moths 2021. Butterfly Conservation, Rothamsted Research and UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Wareham, Dorset, UK.
Attachments:
Object
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy BX24: Beeches Farm and land north of Barnhorn Road
Representation ID: 31762
Received: 15/11/2026
Respondent: Sussex Butterfly Conservation
Legally compliant? Not specified
Sound? Not specified
Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly.
Please see full representation text below
We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
Please see the attached representatioin for original formatting.
Please find below the representation from Sussex Butterfly Conservation (BC) on the above consultation. Sussex BC also submitted a response to the Regulation 18 Local Plan consultation in March 2026.
Butterfly Conservation is the UK charity dedicated to saving butterflies, moths and our natural environment. We are a world-leading authority on the conservation of these beautiful and vital creatures. Butterfly Conservation's strength derives from its 32 Branches and over 40,000 members who help to deliver our key aims to:
• Halve the number of the UK’s threatened species of butterflies and moths
• Improve the condition of 100 of the most important landscapes for butterflies and moths
• Transform 100,000 wild spaces in the UK for people, butterflies and moths
Sussex BC is a member of the Sussex Local Nature Partnership and was involved in the preparation of the recently published East Sussex and Brighton & Hove Local Nature Recovery Strategy.
Butterflies are highly sensitive indicators of the health of the environment and play crucial roles in the food chain as well as being pollinators of plants. In addition, many butterflies and moths are designated in conservation terms as “Priority Species” being species most under threat because of their rarity and/or rate of decline.
In the UK, long-term trends show that 80% of butterfly species have decreased in abundance or distribution, or both since the 1970s. On average, UK butterflies have lost 6% of their total abundance at monitored sites and 42% of their distribution over the period 1976-2019.(1)
The total abundance of larger moths caught in the RIS light-trap network in Britain decreased by 33% over 50 years (1968–2017). Losses were greater in the southern half of Britain (39% decrease).(2)
Government policy (NPPF, August 2026) states that the objective of the policies in Chapter 19 “Conserving and enhancing the natural environment “is to influence the design and location of new development to help drive nature’s recovery and contribute to wider environmental outcomes, safeguarding our most important habitats, species and landscapes and recognising the centrality of natural capital to delivering sustainable growth. Many of the policies set out in Chapter 19 are relevant and pertinent to the protection and enhancement of habitat for butterflies and moths, including paragraphs N1 “Identifying environmental opportunities and safeguards”, N2 “Improving the natural environment” and N6 “Areas of particular importance for biodiversity and geodiversity.”
Sussex BC consider that these national policies should enable proper consideration within Local Plans of conservation of butterflies and moths and their habitats. In this context therefore, Sussex BC wish to make a positive contribution to the Rother Local Plan consultation to ensure that butterflies and moths are protected from development and that opportunities for increasing and enhancing their populations and habitats are secured. Sussex BC would welcome a dialogue with Rother DC on the matters raised below and would be happy to provide further advice on delivering the measures suggested as appropriate. Please find our detailed comments set out below:
1.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT:
The current consultation document includes the identification of a very large number of housing site allocations as well as those for employment and other uses. Some of the site allocations are located close or adjacent to designated wildlife sites, and to areas where the presence of butterflies has been recorded.
As a general principle, Sussex BC wish to see any development of the allocations take place in a way which protects and enhances butterflies and moths and their habitats, including the consideration of priority species, and the delivery of nature recovery.
In this respect Sussex BC notes the inclusion of policies in Chapter 7 on the Natural and Historic Environment and in particular LAN3 Trees, Woodlands and hedgerows, LAN4 Light Pollution and Dark Skies, ENV7 Biodiversity, ENV8 Habitats and species, ENV9 Local Nature Recovery Strategy, ENV10 Biodiversity Net Gain and HRE2 e. Conversion and Reuse of Historic Buildings -Biodiversity features.
These policies are very welcome and Sussex BC support their general aims but would request that they are extended to include measures to protect and enhance butterflies and moths and their habitats. We ask that the following measures relating to habitat creation for butterflies and to reducing light pollution to protect moths are incorporated into the Local Plan. Recommended policy wording is set out below:
a) “From the outset new development design should incorporate the creation of wildlife habitats to benefit butterfly species”
Consideration should be given to design which assists butterfly species at all stages of their lifecycle. Features could include:
a. Butterfly banks – for example “E” shaped
b. Nectar planting
c. Caterpillar food plants
d. Areas for overwintering adults/pupae
b) “New development and local green spaces should be designed and planned from the outset to minimize light pollution which could affect moths.”
Measures could include:
a. Considering appropriate lighting options including siting of light sources for new development
b. Creating Moon Meadows – green spaces free from light pollution. https://butterfly-conservation.org/join-the-dark-side
c. Plant moth-friendly plants alongside no-mow wild areas, in an area free from artificial light.
2. ECOLOGICAL ASSESSMENTS
We note that the requirements for development on many of the site allocations refer to areas for Biodiversity Net Gain, Landscape and Ecological Management Plans, multifunctional Green Infrastructure corridors, and ecological enhancements. We support these requirements and ask that they will include delivery of the measures above. Such improvements will need to be based on comprehensive ecological surveys and we would request that such assessment includes examination of the presence of butterfly and moth species. We would particularly note that to adequately establish which species are present, single surveys are likely to be inadequate, particularly as they will not capture the staggered emergence (as adults from pupae) periods of different species. In addition to visual surveying for adult butterflies, additional methodologies, such as UV searching for larvae and pupae, and winter egg surveying (for Brown Hairstreak eggs) may be appropriate.
While we do not have sufficient knowledge of the individual sites in the Rother Local Plan, we note that their general geographic location makes it a possibility that priority species Grizzled and Dingy Skipper, both very small, inconspicuous and easily overlooked species which emerge in the spring, could be present. White-letter Hairstreak, an Elm dependant (as it's larval food) species could also be present if Elm exists at specific sites, and Brown Hairstreak, similarly dependant on Blackthorn, are expanding eastwards throughout East Sussex and Kent and their colonisation of Rother District in the relatively near future is to be anticipated. The adult butterflies of both these Hairstreak priority species spend much of their time in the canopy of large tress, and can be difficult to locate, even when present at a site. We also note that White Admiral, a priority species, primarily of woodland, and dependant on Honeysuckle as larval food, are recorded adjacent to some allocation sites and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Ecological site surveys and assessments should therefore take account of the possible presence of all of these priority species.
3. PARTICULAR OPPORTUNITIES:
There are many allocations identified in the consultation document which are large both in area and scale of development. These sites would provide particularly good opportunities to incorporate butterfly habitat creation features as well as design to minimise light pollution for moths and we request that these principles are taken into account. In some cases there are sensitive habitats, especially hedgerows, at the edges and on the boundaries of the sites so particular care of these should be taken to protect and enhance these within the development design. We request that an ecological assessment of the site including for butterflies and moths takes place before the development is designed.
4. SITE ALLOCATIONS
a) Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly. We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
b) Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX28 Land at Northeye and adjoining land: some 384 dwellings; community uses which could include outdoor sports facilities including formal playing pitch(es).
BX25 Land at Barnhorn Green for Medical centre/light industrial which requires “a sensitive lighting strategy to avoid impacts on protected species and neighbouring amenity”.
(1) Fox R, Dennis EB, Purdy KM, Middlebrook I, Roy DB, Noble DG, Botham MS & Bourn NAD (2023) The State of the UK’s Butterflies 2022. Butterfly Conservation, Wareham, UK.
(2)Fox R, Dennis EB, Harrower CA, Blumgart D, Bell JR, Cook P, Davis AM, Evans-Hill LJ, Haynes F, Hill D, Isaac NJB, Parsons MS, Pocock MJO, Prescott T, Randle Z, Shortall CR, Tordoff GM, Tuson D & Bourn NAD (2021) The State of Britain’s Larger Moths 2021. Butterfly Conservation, Rothamsted Research and UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Wareham, Dorset, UK.
Attachments:
Object
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy BX38: Land at Freezeland Farm, Freezeland Lane
Representation ID: 31763
Received: 15/11/2026
Respondent: Sussex Butterfly Conservation
Legally compliant? Not specified
Sound? Not specified
Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly.
Please see full representation text below
We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
Please see the attached representatioin for original formatting.
Please find below the representation from Sussex Butterfly Conservation (BC) on the above consultation. Sussex BC also submitted a response to the Regulation 18 Local Plan consultation in March 2026.
Butterfly Conservation is the UK charity dedicated to saving butterflies, moths and our natural environment. We are a world-leading authority on the conservation of these beautiful and vital creatures. Butterfly Conservation's strength derives from its 32 Branches and over 40,000 members who help to deliver our key aims to:
• Halve the number of the UK’s threatened species of butterflies and moths
• Improve the condition of 100 of the most important landscapes for butterflies and moths
• Transform 100,000 wild spaces in the UK for people, butterflies and moths
Sussex BC is a member of the Sussex Local Nature Partnership and was involved in the preparation of the recently published East Sussex and Brighton & Hove Local Nature Recovery Strategy.
Butterflies are highly sensitive indicators of the health of the environment and play crucial roles in the food chain as well as being pollinators of plants. In addition, many butterflies and moths are designated in conservation terms as “Priority Species” being species most under threat because of their rarity and/or rate of decline.
In the UK, long-term trends show that 80% of butterfly species have decreased in abundance or distribution, or both since the 1970s. On average, UK butterflies have lost 6% of their total abundance at monitored sites and 42% of their distribution over the period 1976-2019.(1)
The total abundance of larger moths caught in the RIS light-trap network in Britain decreased by 33% over 50 years (1968–2017). Losses were greater in the southern half of Britain (39% decrease).(2)
Government policy (NPPF, August 2026) states that the objective of the policies in Chapter 19 “Conserving and enhancing the natural environment “is to influence the design and location of new development to help drive nature’s recovery and contribute to wider environmental outcomes, safeguarding our most important habitats, species and landscapes and recognising the centrality of natural capital to delivering sustainable growth. Many of the policies set out in Chapter 19 are relevant and pertinent to the protection and enhancement of habitat for butterflies and moths, including paragraphs N1 “Identifying environmental opportunities and safeguards”, N2 “Improving the natural environment” and N6 “Areas of particular importance for biodiversity and geodiversity.”
Sussex BC consider that these national policies should enable proper consideration within Local Plans of conservation of butterflies and moths and their habitats. In this context therefore, Sussex BC wish to make a positive contribution to the Rother Local Plan consultation to ensure that butterflies and moths are protected from development and that opportunities for increasing and enhancing their populations and habitats are secured. Sussex BC would welcome a dialogue with Rother DC on the matters raised below and would be happy to provide further advice on delivering the measures suggested as appropriate. Please find our detailed comments set out below:
1.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT:
The current consultation document includes the identification of a very large number of housing site allocations as well as those for employment and other uses. Some of the site allocations are located close or adjacent to designated wildlife sites, and to areas where the presence of butterflies has been recorded.
As a general principle, Sussex BC wish to see any development of the allocations take place in a way which protects and enhances butterflies and moths and their habitats, including the consideration of priority species, and the delivery of nature recovery.
In this respect Sussex BC notes the inclusion of policies in Chapter 7 on the Natural and Historic Environment and in particular LAN3 Trees, Woodlands and hedgerows, LAN4 Light Pollution and Dark Skies, ENV7 Biodiversity, ENV8 Habitats and species, ENV9 Local Nature Recovery Strategy, ENV10 Biodiversity Net Gain and HRE2 e. Conversion and Reuse of Historic Buildings -Biodiversity features.
These policies are very welcome and Sussex BC support their general aims but would request that they are extended to include measures to protect and enhance butterflies and moths and their habitats. We ask that the following measures relating to habitat creation for butterflies and to reducing light pollution to protect moths are incorporated into the Local Plan. Recommended policy wording is set out below:
a) “From the outset new development design should incorporate the creation of wildlife habitats to benefit butterfly species”
Consideration should be given to design which assists butterfly species at all stages of their lifecycle. Features could include:
a. Butterfly banks – for example “E” shaped
b. Nectar planting
c. Caterpillar food plants
d. Areas for overwintering adults/pupae
b) “New development and local green spaces should be designed and planned from the outset to minimize light pollution which could affect moths.”
Measures could include:
a. Considering appropriate lighting options including siting of light sources for new development
b. Creating Moon Meadows – green spaces free from light pollution. https://butterfly-conservation.org/join-the-dark-side
c. Plant moth-friendly plants alongside no-mow wild areas, in an area free from artificial light.
2. ECOLOGICAL ASSESSMENTS
We note that the requirements for development on many of the site allocations refer to areas for Biodiversity Net Gain, Landscape and Ecological Management Plans, multifunctional Green Infrastructure corridors, and ecological enhancements. We support these requirements and ask that they will include delivery of the measures above. Such improvements will need to be based on comprehensive ecological surveys and we would request that such assessment includes examination of the presence of butterfly and moth species. We would particularly note that to adequately establish which species are present, single surveys are likely to be inadequate, particularly as they will not capture the staggered emergence (as adults from pupae) periods of different species. In addition to visual surveying for adult butterflies, additional methodologies, such as UV searching for larvae and pupae, and winter egg surveying (for Brown Hairstreak eggs) may be appropriate.
While we do not have sufficient knowledge of the individual sites in the Rother Local Plan, we note that their general geographic location makes it a possibility that priority species Grizzled and Dingy Skipper, both very small, inconspicuous and easily overlooked species which emerge in the spring, could be present. White-letter Hairstreak, an Elm dependant (as it's larval food) species could also be present if Elm exists at specific sites, and Brown Hairstreak, similarly dependant on Blackthorn, are expanding eastwards throughout East Sussex and Kent and their colonisation of Rother District in the relatively near future is to be anticipated. The adult butterflies of both these Hairstreak priority species spend much of their time in the canopy of large tress, and can be difficult to locate, even when present at a site. We also note that White Admiral, a priority species, primarily of woodland, and dependant on Honeysuckle as larval food, are recorded adjacent to some allocation sites and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Ecological site surveys and assessments should therefore take account of the possible presence of all of these priority species.
3. PARTICULAR OPPORTUNITIES:
There are many allocations identified in the consultation document which are large both in area and scale of development. These sites would provide particularly good opportunities to incorporate butterfly habitat creation features as well as design to minimise light pollution for moths and we request that these principles are taken into account. In some cases there are sensitive habitats, especially hedgerows, at the edges and on the boundaries of the sites so particular care of these should be taken to protect and enhance these within the development design. We request that an ecological assessment of the site including for butterflies and moths takes place before the development is designed.
4. SITE ALLOCATIONS
a) Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly. We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
b) Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX28 Land at Northeye and adjoining land: some 384 dwellings; community uses which could include outdoor sports facilities including formal playing pitch(es).
BX25 Land at Barnhorn Green for Medical centre/light industrial which requires “a sensitive lighting strategy to avoid impacts on protected species and neighbouring amenity”.
(1) Fox R, Dennis EB, Purdy KM, Middlebrook I, Roy DB, Noble DG, Botham MS & Bourn NAD (2023) The State of the UK’s Butterflies 2022. Butterfly Conservation, Wareham, UK.
(2)Fox R, Dennis EB, Harrower CA, Blumgart D, Bell JR, Cook P, Davis AM, Evans-Hill LJ, Haynes F, Hill D, Isaac NJB, Parsons MS, Pocock MJO, Prescott T, Randle Z, Shortall CR, Tordoff GM, Tuson D & Bourn NAD (2021) The State of Britain’s Larger Moths 2021. Butterfly Conservation, Rothamsted Research and UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Wareham, Dorset, UK.
Attachments:
Object
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy BX25: Land at Northeye and adjoining land
Representation ID: 31764
Received: 15/11/2026
Respondent: Sussex Butterfly Conservation
Legally compliant? Not specified
Sound? Not specified
Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX25 Land at Barnhorn Green for Medical centre/light industrial which requires “a sensitive lighting strategy to avoid impacts on protected species and neighbouring amenity”.
Please see full representation text below
Please see the attached representatioin for original formatting.
Please find below the representation from Sussex Butterfly Conservation (BC) on the above consultation. Sussex BC also submitted a response to the Regulation 18 Local Plan consultation in March 2026.
Butterfly Conservation is the UK charity dedicated to saving butterflies, moths and our natural environment. We are a world-leading authority on the conservation of these beautiful and vital creatures. Butterfly Conservation's strength derives from its 32 Branches and over 40,000 members who help to deliver our key aims to:
• Halve the number of the UK’s threatened species of butterflies and moths
• Improve the condition of 100 of the most important landscapes for butterflies and moths
• Transform 100,000 wild spaces in the UK for people, butterflies and moths
Sussex BC is a member of the Sussex Local Nature Partnership and was involved in the preparation of the recently published East Sussex and Brighton & Hove Local Nature Recovery Strategy.
Butterflies are highly sensitive indicators of the health of the environment and play crucial roles in the food chain as well as being pollinators of plants. In addition, many butterflies and moths are designated in conservation terms as “Priority Species” being species most under threat because of their rarity and/or rate of decline.
In the UK, long-term trends show that 80% of butterfly species have decreased in abundance or distribution, or both since the 1970s. On average, UK butterflies have lost 6% of their total abundance at monitored sites and 42% of their distribution over the period 1976-2019.(1)
The total abundance of larger moths caught in the RIS light-trap network in Britain decreased by 33% over 50 years (1968–2017). Losses were greater in the southern half of Britain (39% decrease).(2)
Government policy (NPPF, August 2026) states that the objective of the policies in Chapter 19 “Conserving and enhancing the natural environment “is to influence the design and location of new development to help drive nature’s recovery and contribute to wider environmental outcomes, safeguarding our most important habitats, species and landscapes and recognising the centrality of natural capital to delivering sustainable growth. Many of the policies set out in Chapter 19 are relevant and pertinent to the protection and enhancement of habitat for butterflies and moths, including paragraphs N1 “Identifying environmental opportunities and safeguards”, N2 “Improving the natural environment” and N6 “Areas of particular importance for biodiversity and geodiversity.”
Sussex BC consider that these national policies should enable proper consideration within Local Plans of conservation of butterflies and moths and their habitats. In this context therefore, Sussex BC wish to make a positive contribution to the Rother Local Plan consultation to ensure that butterflies and moths are protected from development and that opportunities for increasing and enhancing their populations and habitats are secured. Sussex BC would welcome a dialogue with Rother DC on the matters raised below and would be happy to provide further advice on delivering the measures suggested as appropriate. Please find our detailed comments set out below:
1.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT:
The current consultation document includes the identification of a very large number of housing site allocations as well as those for employment and other uses. Some of the site allocations are located close or adjacent to designated wildlife sites, and to areas where the presence of butterflies has been recorded.
As a general principle, Sussex BC wish to see any development of the allocations take place in a way which protects and enhances butterflies and moths and their habitats, including the consideration of priority species, and the delivery of nature recovery.
In this respect Sussex BC notes the inclusion of policies in Chapter 7 on the Natural and Historic Environment and in particular LAN3 Trees, Woodlands and hedgerows, LAN4 Light Pollution and Dark Skies, ENV7 Biodiversity, ENV8 Habitats and species, ENV9 Local Nature Recovery Strategy, ENV10 Biodiversity Net Gain and HRE2 e. Conversion and Reuse of Historic Buildings -Biodiversity features.
These policies are very welcome and Sussex BC support their general aims but would request that they are extended to include measures to protect and enhance butterflies and moths and their habitats. We ask that the following measures relating to habitat creation for butterflies and to reducing light pollution to protect moths are incorporated into the Local Plan. Recommended policy wording is set out below:
a) “From the outset new development design should incorporate the creation of wildlife habitats to benefit butterfly species”
Consideration should be given to design which assists butterfly species at all stages of their lifecycle. Features could include:
a. Butterfly banks – for example “E” shaped
b. Nectar planting
c. Caterpillar food plants
d. Areas for overwintering adults/pupae
b) “New development and local green spaces should be designed and planned from the outset to minimize light pollution which could affect moths.”
Measures could include:
a. Considering appropriate lighting options including siting of light sources for new development
b. Creating Moon Meadows – green spaces free from light pollution. https://butterfly-conservation.org/join-the-dark-side
c. Plant moth-friendly plants alongside no-mow wild areas, in an area free from artificial light.
2. ECOLOGICAL ASSESSMENTS
We note that the requirements for development on many of the site allocations refer to areas for Biodiversity Net Gain, Landscape and Ecological Management Plans, multifunctional Green Infrastructure corridors, and ecological enhancements. We support these requirements and ask that they will include delivery of the measures above. Such improvements will need to be based on comprehensive ecological surveys and we would request that such assessment includes examination of the presence of butterfly and moth species. We would particularly note that to adequately establish which species are present, single surveys are likely to be inadequate, particularly as they will not capture the staggered emergence (as adults from pupae) periods of different species. In addition to visual surveying for adult butterflies, additional methodologies, such as UV searching for larvae and pupae, and winter egg surveying (for Brown Hairstreak eggs) may be appropriate.
While we do not have sufficient knowledge of the individual sites in the Rother Local Plan, we note that their general geographic location makes it a possibility that priority species Grizzled and Dingy Skipper, both very small, inconspicuous and easily overlooked species which emerge in the spring, could be present. White-letter Hairstreak, an Elm dependant (as it's larval food) species could also be present if Elm exists at specific sites, and Brown Hairstreak, similarly dependant on Blackthorn, are expanding eastwards throughout East Sussex and Kent and their colonisation of Rother District in the relatively near future is to be anticipated. The adult butterflies of both these Hairstreak priority species spend much of their time in the canopy of large tress, and can be difficult to locate, even when present at a site. We also note that White Admiral, a priority species, primarily of woodland, and dependant on Honeysuckle as larval food, are recorded adjacent to some allocation sites and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Ecological site surveys and assessments should therefore take account of the possible presence of all of these priority species.
3. PARTICULAR OPPORTUNITIES:
There are many allocations identified in the consultation document which are large both in area and scale of development. These sites would provide particularly good opportunities to incorporate butterfly habitat creation features as well as design to minimise light pollution for moths and we request that these principles are taken into account. In some cases there are sensitive habitats, especially hedgerows, at the edges and on the boundaries of the sites so particular care of these should be taken to protect and enhance these within the development design. We request that an ecological assessment of the site including for butterflies and moths takes place before the development is designed.
4. SITE ALLOCATIONS
a) Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly. We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
b) Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX28 Land at Northeye and adjoining land: some 384 dwellings; community uses which could include outdoor sports facilities including formal playing pitch(es).
BX25 Land at Barnhorn Green for Medical centre/light industrial which requires “a sensitive lighting strategy to avoid impacts on protected species and neighbouring amenity”.
(1) Fox R, Dennis EB, Purdy KM, Middlebrook I, Roy DB, Noble DG, Botham MS & Bourn NAD (2023) The State of the UK’s Butterflies 2022. Butterfly Conservation, Wareham, UK.
(2)Fox R, Dennis EB, Harrower CA, Blumgart D, Bell JR, Cook P, Davis AM, Evans-Hill LJ, Haynes F, Hill D, Isaac NJB, Parsons MS, Pocock MJO, Prescott T, Randle Z, Shortall CR, Tordoff GM, Tuson D & Bourn NAD (2021) The State of Britain’s Larger Moths 2021. Butterfly Conservation, Rothamsted Research and UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Wareham, Dorset, UK.
Attachments:
Object
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy BX28: Land at Kiteye Farm
Representation ID: 31765
Received: 15/11/2026
Respondent: Sussex Butterfly Conservation
Legally compliant? Not specified
Sound? Not specified
Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX28 Land at Northeye and adjoining land: some 384 dwellings; community uses which could include outdoor sports facilities including formal playing pitch(es).
Please see full representation text below
Please see the attached representatioin for original formatting.
Please find below the representation from Sussex Butterfly Conservation (BC) on the above consultation. Sussex BC also submitted a response to the Regulation 18 Local Plan consultation in March 2026.
Butterfly Conservation is the UK charity dedicated to saving butterflies, moths and our natural environment. We are a world-leading authority on the conservation of these beautiful and vital creatures. Butterfly Conservation's strength derives from its 32 Branches and over 40,000 members who help to deliver our key aims to:
• Halve the number of the UK’s threatened species of butterflies and moths
• Improve the condition of 100 of the most important landscapes for butterflies and moths
• Transform 100,000 wild spaces in the UK for people, butterflies and moths
Sussex BC is a member of the Sussex Local Nature Partnership and was involved in the preparation of the recently published East Sussex and Brighton & Hove Local Nature Recovery Strategy.
Butterflies are highly sensitive indicators of the health of the environment and play crucial roles in the food chain as well as being pollinators of plants. In addition, many butterflies and moths are designated in conservation terms as “Priority Species” being species most under threat because of their rarity and/or rate of decline.
In the UK, long-term trends show that 80% of butterfly species have decreased in abundance or distribution, or both since the 1970s. On average, UK butterflies have lost 6% of their total abundance at monitored sites and 42% of their distribution over the period 1976-2019.(1)
The total abundance of larger moths caught in the RIS light-trap network in Britain decreased by 33% over 50 years (1968–2017). Losses were greater in the southern half of Britain (39% decrease).(2)
Government policy (NPPF, August 2026) states that the objective of the policies in Chapter 19 “Conserving and enhancing the natural environment “is to influence the design and location of new development to help drive nature’s recovery and contribute to wider environmental outcomes, safeguarding our most important habitats, species and landscapes and recognising the centrality of natural capital to delivering sustainable growth. Many of the policies set out in Chapter 19 are relevant and pertinent to the protection and enhancement of habitat for butterflies and moths, including paragraphs N1 “Identifying environmental opportunities and safeguards”, N2 “Improving the natural environment” and N6 “Areas of particular importance for biodiversity and geodiversity.”
Sussex BC consider that these national policies should enable proper consideration within Local Plans of conservation of butterflies and moths and their habitats. In this context therefore, Sussex BC wish to make a positive contribution to the Rother Local Plan consultation to ensure that butterflies and moths are protected from development and that opportunities for increasing and enhancing their populations and habitats are secured. Sussex BC would welcome a dialogue with Rother DC on the matters raised below and would be happy to provide further advice on delivering the measures suggested as appropriate. Please find our detailed comments set out below:
1.ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND ENHANCEMENT:
The current consultation document includes the identification of a very large number of housing site allocations as well as those for employment and other uses. Some of the site allocations are located close or adjacent to designated wildlife sites, and to areas where the presence of butterflies has been recorded.
As a general principle, Sussex BC wish to see any development of the allocations take place in a way which protects and enhances butterflies and moths and their habitats, including the consideration of priority species, and the delivery of nature recovery.
In this respect Sussex BC notes the inclusion of policies in Chapter 7 on the Natural and Historic Environment and in particular LAN3 Trees, Woodlands and hedgerows, LAN4 Light Pollution and Dark Skies, ENV7 Biodiversity, ENV8 Habitats and species, ENV9 Local Nature Recovery Strategy, ENV10 Biodiversity Net Gain and HRE2 e. Conversion and Reuse of Historic Buildings -Biodiversity features.
These policies are very welcome and Sussex BC support their general aims but would request that they are extended to include measures to protect and enhance butterflies and moths and their habitats. We ask that the following measures relating to habitat creation for butterflies and to reducing light pollution to protect moths are incorporated into the Local Plan. Recommended policy wording is set out below:
a) “From the outset new development design should incorporate the creation of wildlife habitats to benefit butterfly species”
Consideration should be given to design which assists butterfly species at all stages of their lifecycle. Features could include:
a. Butterfly banks – for example “E” shaped
b. Nectar planting
c. Caterpillar food plants
d. Areas for overwintering adults/pupae
b) “New development and local green spaces should be designed and planned from the outset to minimize light pollution which could affect moths.”
Measures could include:
a. Considering appropriate lighting options including siting of light sources for new development
b. Creating Moon Meadows – green spaces free from light pollution. https://butterfly-conservation.org/join-the-dark-side
c. Plant moth-friendly plants alongside no-mow wild areas, in an area free from artificial light.
2. ECOLOGICAL ASSESSMENTS
We note that the requirements for development on many of the site allocations refer to areas for Biodiversity Net Gain, Landscape and Ecological Management Plans, multifunctional Green Infrastructure corridors, and ecological enhancements. We support these requirements and ask that they will include delivery of the measures above. Such improvements will need to be based on comprehensive ecological surveys and we would request that such assessment includes examination of the presence of butterfly and moth species. We would particularly note that to adequately establish which species are present, single surveys are likely to be inadequate, particularly as they will not capture the staggered emergence (as adults from pupae) periods of different species. In addition to visual surveying for adult butterflies, additional methodologies, such as UV searching for larvae and pupae, and winter egg surveying (for Brown Hairstreak eggs) may be appropriate.
While we do not have sufficient knowledge of the individual sites in the Rother Local Plan, we note that their general geographic location makes it a possibility that priority species Grizzled and Dingy Skipper, both very small, inconspicuous and easily overlooked species which emerge in the spring, could be present. White-letter Hairstreak, an Elm dependant (as it's larval food) species could also be present if Elm exists at specific sites, and Brown Hairstreak, similarly dependant on Blackthorn, are expanding eastwards throughout East Sussex and Kent and their colonisation of Rother District in the relatively near future is to be anticipated. The adult butterflies of both these Hairstreak priority species spend much of their time in the canopy of large tress, and can be difficult to locate, even when present at a site. We also note that White Admiral, a priority species, primarily of woodland, and dependant on Honeysuckle as larval food, are recorded adjacent to some allocation sites and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Ecological site surveys and assessments should therefore take account of the possible presence of all of these priority species.
3. PARTICULAR OPPORTUNITIES:
There are many allocations identified in the consultation document which are large both in area and scale of development. These sites would provide particularly good opportunities to incorporate butterfly habitat creation features as well as design to minimise light pollution for moths and we request that these principles are taken into account. In some cases there are sensitive habitats, especially hedgerows, at the edges and on the boundaries of the sites so particular care of these should be taken to protect and enhance these within the development design. We request that an ecological assessment of the site including for butterflies and moths takes place before the development is designed.
4. SITE ALLOCATIONS
a) Sightings of the White Admiral, a priority butterfly species, have been recorded adjacent to sites BX23, BX24 and BX38, and could potentially occur in proximity to other sites. Sussex BC are concerned that these proposed development sites could adversely affect adjoining habitat which may support this priority species butterfly. We therefore request that an appropriate ecological assessment is carried out on each site to fully assess the potential impact of the development on lepidoptera and whether suitable mitigation (including green infrastructure) could be achieved as part of the development proposal.
b) Light pollution – sites BX25 and BX25 below involve proposals which by their nature could result in excess light affecting moths and other species. We request that this matter is taken account of at the design stage of each development to avoid any adverse impacts.
BX28 Land at Northeye and adjoining land: some 384 dwellings; community uses which could include outdoor sports facilities including formal playing pitch(es).
BX25 Land at Barnhorn Green for Medical centre/light industrial which requires “a sensitive lighting strategy to avoid impacts on protected species and neighbouring amenity”.
(1) Fox R, Dennis EB, Purdy KM, Middlebrook I, Roy DB, Noble DG, Botham MS & Bourn NAD (2023) The State of the UK’s Butterflies 2022. Butterfly Conservation, Wareham, UK.
(2)Fox R, Dennis EB, Harrower CA, Blumgart D, Bell JR, Cook P, Davis AM, Evans-Hill LJ, Haynes F, Hill D, Isaac NJB, Parsons MS, Pocock MJO, Prescott T, Randle Z, Shortall CR, Tordoff GM, Tuson D & Bourn NAD (2021) The State of Britain’s Larger Moths 2021. Butterfly Conservation, Rothamsted Research and UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology, Wareham, Dorset, UK.