Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Search representations
Results for Sea Change Sussex search
New search New searchObject
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy GTC1: Net Zero Development
Representation ID: 31751
Received: 13/11/2026
Respondent: Sea Change Sussex
Legally compliant? No
Sound? No
Please see attached objection to Policy GTC1 for full submission.
Requirement 6 of Policy GTC1 is considered unsound, inconsistent with national policy, insufficiently justified, ineffective and potentially legally non-compliant. The requirement is said to depart from the Government’s preferred Building Regulations-based approach to energy efficiency and is not supported by an up-to-date evidence base for commercial development. We have concerns regarding the achievability of the proposed LETI Energy Use Intensity (EUI) targets and the extent to which they recognise alternative net-zero pathways, including onsite renewable energy generation. The methodology is considered to rely on assumptions about occupier behaviour and the energy use of portable appliances, creating uncertainty and potential difficulties in implementation. The regulation of “unregulated energy” extends beyond the appropriate scope of the planning system. A Target Emissions Rate (TER) approach aligned with Building Regulations is proposed instead.
Alternative Policy suggestion - Policy GTC1: Net Zero Development
We would suggest that the use of a Local Energy Standard should only be adopted if the is a robust current evince base in place to support it. Regrettably Rother District Council Rother Climate Change Study July 2023, provides policy recommendations based on a National Policy position that was superseded in December 2023, and is as such outdated, and the subsequent Rother District Council Energy Efficiency Standards Study October 2026 covers only residential buildings.
We recognise that RDC have attempted to bring the policy into compliance by expressing parts of the policy target in TER within the explanatory text, this however only provides guidance on residential use buildings, leaving non-residential building to be assessed on demonstrably vague criteria.
As the vagueness in the proposed criteria would allow two development control officers acting reasonably and making reasonable assumptions to reach contradicting conclusions as to the acceptability of a building in planning terms the policy is ineffective and could result in inconsistent decisions.
We would suggest that in order to deliver a sound policy all requirements should be assessed in line with TER as set out in National Policy, and that the assessment method applied should be based upon the SAP methodology utilised for building regulations compliance. This approach would be applying standard benchmark assumptions on how buildings are used that have been developed based on use data and allow the assessment to gauge how a typical operator would utilise the property.
We would suggest that for the purpose of regulating land use and assessing the performance of buildings at the planning stage for regulatory purposes that standardised assumptions will produce more consistent results, that can be assesses in a consistent manner without the undue burden of introducing a somewhat subjective standard into the planning process.
We would suggest that targets should also incorporate energy from renewables so as to incentivise the exploration of this option by developers. Given that Bexhill is one of the sunniest towns in the UK it offers considerable potential for solar to play a substantive role in decarbonisation.
In our view the LETI EUI approach, while useful for building designers in estimating energy use for occupiers, is not appropriate for use within the planning system as it utilises an occupier specific approach which would require a large number of potentially subjective assumptions on user behaviour to be made at the planning stage.
Please see attached objection on Policy GTC1: Net Zero Development for full text.
We consider requirement 6 of this policy to be unsound as it is inconsistent with national policy, is not justified by a sufficiently up to date evidence base in respect to commercial property, is potentially ineffective due to the non-standard measurement approach proposed, and is in our opinion potentially legally non-compliant.
Why we consider Requirement 6 of this policy inconsistent with national policy National policy on Local energy standards was clarified in the Written Ministerial Statement (WMS) made on 13 December 2023 which is included below for reference.
This policy sets out a clear requirement to reject local energy standards unless a well-reasoned and robustly costed rationale that ensures:
• That development remains viable, and the impact on housing supply and affordability is considered in accordance with the National Planning Policy Framework.
• The additional requirement is expressed as a percentage uplift of a dwelling’s Target Emissions Rate (TER) calculated using a specified version of the Standard Assessment Procedure (SAP).
The WMS also imposes a requirement that where plan policies go beyond current or planned building regulations, those polices should be applied flexibly to decisions on planning applications and appeals where the applicant can demonstrate that meeting the higher standards is not technically feasible.
In this regard the intent of national policy is to limit duplication between building regulations and the emergence of bespoke local standards that add complexity to the development process.
While the WMS is drafted in manner that applies to housing its principles should be applied similarly to commercial property. In this regard the draft requirements do not conform to the TER based approach that government has sought to standardise as the approach across the country.
Why we consider Requirement 6 not sufficiently justified
First and foremost, we must highlight that the evidence base in respect of commercial property requirements remains Rother District Council Rother Climate Change Study July 2023, and the subsequent Rother District Council Energy Efficiency Standards Study October 2026 covers only residential buildings.
The 2023 evidence base provides policy recommendations based on a National Policy position that was superseded in December 2023 and is as such outdated as it cannot be said to have considered the current National Planning Policy position. The current approach appears not to have considered the application of a consistent approach within the available evidence base.
comment on this we have considered the justification for this policy by posing the following questions.
a) Is the scale and pace of change in energy use reduction targeted necessary?
In order to assess the reasonableness, feasibility and need for these targets we have undertaken a comparison with The Non-Domestic National Energy Efficiency Data-Framework 2026 (England and Wales) - 30 September 2026 which provides the latest Official Statistics on median energy use intensity with 2024 being the latest year for which official statistics have been published by government.
The chart below illustrates the scale of reduction in energy use that would be required to meet these targets against median in all use categories used by the Non-Domestic National Energy Efficiency Data-Framework 2026.
It should be noted that the figures produced by the Non-Domestic National Energy Efficiency Data-Framework 2026’ consumption figures comprise electricity and gas consumed via the public distribution system (onsite generated electricity consumption is not included), and despite this the total median energy consumption has fallen on average by around 3.2% over the last 12 years.
5.3.13 If reductions continue at a similar pace energy use intensity will reduce to levels in line with Net Zero ambitions before the national policy target of 2050. This is therefore not indicative a need for typical local authority areas to accelerate energy use reduction.
5.3.14 While newer buildings are generally more efficient, we believe that achieving a reduction of more than 70% in office settings, is not a reasonably deliverable target to achieve in all new buildings from the adoption of the plan forward. A more gradual approach appears to remain possible while allowing time for industry to adapt and supply chains to grow to sufficient capacity.
5.3.15 The official statistics clearly indicate that to a significant degree energy use intensity is determined by the use rather than the building. A good example of this is that despite often being in the same buildings office uses typically use less than half the energy of hospitality-based uses. This would suggest that an approach that applies EUI rates based on offices and industrial uses is overly simplistic, and that applying these rates to other uses as is proposed would not be appropriate as the gap between typical EUI and the policy target varies widely by use.
5.3.16 This policy seeks for non-residential new builds to deliver energy use reductions equivalent to over 20x the average annual rate of improvement in the existing stock immediately, which is in our view an unprecedented reduction in energy use, that is unrealistic to assume can be achieved at the start of the plan period.
5.3.17 It is clear given the magnitude of these targets that if achievable they would require substantive changes in business operational practices to be met, that would go beyond simply changes to the building, and would in line with the proposed LETI EUI standard and the TM54:2022 Standard which it relies upon require consideration of even small power appliances, such as IT equipment, printers, lamps and other equipment normally outside the scope of planning control.
5.3.18 In our view the application of a EUI target policy calculated via the LETI EUI standard with policy targets net zero performance at the start of this local plan period based only on office and industrial typographies, and unspecified targets for other commercial uses is not a sufficiently justified approach given the general pace of improvement under national standards.
b) Is onsite renewable energy production an alternate route that is likely to outpace the need for energy use reduction within the plan period?
In the case of the LETI EUI application proposed, the technical requirement for net zero is based on energy consumption and no credit is given for renewable generation. We would question if this an efficient and effective policy in terms of reducing emissions, as clearly renewable energy production is an alternate option to deliver a net zero building. – for example, to illustrate this alternative, the typical factory use EUI is currently around 96 kWh/m2/year, based on the official statistics contained in the Non-Domestic National Energy Efficiency Data-Framework 2026, and solar panels that are commercially available can deliver around 284 kWh per sqm per year based on a 20% efficiency in Bexhill meaning that an industrial building with less than 35% of its roof covered in unshaded solar panels could achieve zero energy consumption at the meter.
Furthermore, we would highlight that there are several factors that make the case for Net zero by onsite renewables appear as though it will progressively be easier to achieve. This includes;
• That most of the current typical energy use in factories is Gas and that energy demand will likely decrease considerably as buildings switch from gas to Heat Pumps which have an effective efficiency of 300%-500%. Reducing energy consumption considerably.
• That new solar panel technologies commercially available can now exceed 25% efficiency, with solar cells under development such as combined perovskite-silicon tandem solar cells have pushed records past 34% to 35%, it is realistic to consider it probable that on site generation could reach 355kWh per sqm per year on south facing roofs in the early part of the plan period moving towards 500 kWh per sqm per year by the end of the plan period, based on technology that is already in the testing phase.
We would therefore suggest that a building constructed in a manner that exceeds the energy use intensity specified in the draft policy, while being a genuine Net Zero property is entirely possible.
We do not consider the evidence base to sufficiently justify why policy must choose between a fabric first or renewable first route to Net Zero, and would suggest that in light of global supply chain issues in recent years, a policy that allows both routes would be preferable.
In summary we are of the view that there is sufficient evidence to illustrate that the LETI EUI based approach of restricting energy use is not the only way to net zero. We would suggest that there are many reasons a less restrictive approach to net zero should be considered. There is no particular justification to limit development to a singular approach to achieving net zero and doing so would stifle potential for innovative approaches to resolving an issue where innovative approaches should be embraced.
Why we consider the policy potentially ineffective
The LETI EUI approach is in our opinion ineffective as it relies upon the TM54:2022 Standard and incorporates ‘Unregulated Energy’ use coving items such as plug in portable electronic appliances into equations used to inform the planning process.
While we consider the inclusion of plug-in loads unlawful and have set this position out below in our section on legal compliance. We are of the view that the use of this standard creates considerable potential for inconsistency in the decision-making process by creating a situation where two development control officers both working on reasonable assumptions may reach differing conclusions on a proposals compliance with policy.
Our own calculations of EUI carried out in line with TM54:2022 - Step 5: Evaluating energy use for small power, to model the EUI of a typical workstation PC in a design office or similar application, and the use of a thin end client pc, shown below provide an illustration of this issue.
Scenario A - Assumed Workstation PC on site.
• Professional Services offices usually provide 12sqm of space per employee (based on the HCA Employment Densities guide 3rd edition)
• A Workstation PC for CAD, graphic design, Video Editing etc. utilises around 1,113.2 kWh / annum – based on a 550W machine utilised for 8 hours a day, 253 days per year (the normal number of working days in the year in England excluding leap years). – a total of 2,024 annual hours of operation.
• In addition to this a PC will draw around 5w in sleep mode therefore adding
o 0.005kW x (8760-2024) =33.68kwh / annum
• This gives a total Annual energy consumption of 1146.88 kWh/ annum
• With an area of 12 sqm per workstation, this generates an EUI of 95.6 kWh/m2/annum for total energy consumption simply for running a Workstation PC, taking total energy consumption over policy requirements without allowance for lighting, heating, or any other necessities.
Scenario B – assumed 15W thin-end client instead of a workstation PC
• Professional Services offices usually provide 12sqm of space per employee (based on the HCA Employment Densities guide 3rd edition)
• A Workstation PC for CAD, graphic design, Video Editing etc. utilises around 30.36 kWh / annum – based on a 15W machine utilised for 8 hours a day, 253 days per year (the normal number of working days in the year in England excluding leap years). – a total of 2,024 annual hours of operation.
• In addition to this a PC will draw around 5w in sleep mode therefore adding
o 0.005kW x (8760-2024) =33.68kwh / annum
• This gives a total Annual energy consumption of 64.04 kWh/ annum
• With an area of 12 sqm per workstation, this generates an EUI of 5.3 kWh/m2/annum for total energy consumption simply for running a Workstation PC, taking total energy consumption over policy requirements without allowance for lighting, heating, or any other necessities.
In this case we would suggest that having a Workstation PC or a Thin End Client PC included in modelling are both reasonable solutions for IT provision that an occupier might choose to install. But would highlight that in assessment the difference in EUI result can vary by over 90 kWh/m2/annum on this decision alone.
Given the impact that this choice in modelling will have we would suggest that as changing PC or other similar appliances are not activities within the scope of regulation by the planning system that in practice, what is likely to happen is that developments will be modelled with plug in equipment that has low on-site energy use. Then once any conditions related to EUI have been complied with occupiers will freely make changes that are beyond the scope of the planning system, to this equipment doing things like plugging in lamps, kettles, phone chargers etc.
In practice therefore the likely outcome is that by adopting a policy that model’s specific equipment, compliance will be achieved with a lower standard of building than if a Standardised assessment method using average energy use benchmarks were adopted, as there is no legal planning mechanism that would allow the use of conditions or planning agreements to prevent occupiers subsequently plugging in more equipment subsequently, as plugging something in is not development.
In short this creates a scenario where rather than assessing energy use with a typical occupier, planners are likely to receive assessments of use by a very minimal energy use occupier and then be unable to enforce compliance with the suggested specification post completion by the building’s eventual occupiers.
Our view is that the policy in this regard is ineffective as it is clearly possible to manipulate the EUI in a way that could substantively sway decision making without adopting any unreasonable positions, and it is likely that this will deliver lower energy performance than a standardised TER approach in line with building regulations where typical use assumptions are applied.
We would also highlight that in respect the requirement “For general industrial and warehousing buildings (Class B2, B8 and associated Sui Generis), a feasibility statement to evidence a practicable TEUI Target;” is also ineffective as it sets no fixed target at which a developer can comply and expect to achieve planning permission, and is entirely open to interpretation.
Overall we consider the requirements to encompass processes that allow variation and inconsistency in outcomes contrary to the requirements of national planning policy for local plans to provide a clear and consistent decision making basis.
Why we consider the requirement potentially legally non-compliant
Our primary concern over legal compliance is that the incorporation of the LETI EUI standard into planning policy would bring what is described in Appendix 1 of the LETI Operational Modelling Guide as ‘Unregulated Energy’ which includes all equipment plugged into the wall and all process loads such as catering kitchens and server rooms. Our position is that ‘Unregulated Energy’ use relates to matters that fall outside the legal scope of the planning system.
We would highlight that Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment [1981] AC 578 the House of Lords established that planning requirements must:
• Serve a planning purpose;
• Fairly and reasonably relate to the development permitted; and
• Be reasonable
The Newbury Criteria were subsequently tightened in Westminster City Council v Great Portland Estates plc [1985] confirmed that a planning purpose is ‘one which relates to the character of the use of the land’.
While we recognise that carbon emission reduction is a valid planning purpose, and Net Zero considerations have long been held to be valid Material Considerations, we would suggest that the consideration of planning policy utilising the TM54:2022 standard utilised by the LETI EUI standard proposed incorporates matters that do not fairly and reasonably relate to the development permitted, or indeed land use – for example the explicit consideration of power use by plug in electronic devices that are by nature portable and not a permanent part of the development at a device level.
In this regard we would highlight that the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, Section 55 defines development as;
“development,” means the carrying out of building, engineering, mining or other operations in, on, over or under land, or the making of any material change in the use of any buildings or other land.
Section 55 (2) provides additional clarity to what is not development by stating the following;
“The following operations or uses of land shall not be taken for the purposes of this Act to involve development of the land—
(a)the carrying out for the maintenance, improvement or other alteration of any building of works which—
(i)affect only the interior of the building, or
(ii)do not materially affect the external appearance of the building,
and are not works for making good war damage or works begun after 5th December 1968 for the alteration of a building by providing additional space in it underground; …..”
In the context of Section 55 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, something that is not fixed to the property or development and is both temporary and portable by nature such as a plug-in appliance like a laptop or desktop PC, would not generally be considered part of a development.
We would suggest also that applying the test established by Great Portland the purpose of regulating the energy use of plug-in electrical items is not a purpose ‘which relates to the character of the use of the land’ as simply put minor changes such as whether a desktop PC or a laptop is used by the occupier are far to temporary and trivial in nature to be reasonably considered to impact the character of the use of the land or to amount to development, and as such their regulation via the Planning System is legally inappropriate as it extends beyond the scope of matters the planning system is intended to consider.
Turning to the second limb of the Newbury Criteria, we would suggest that the plug-in appliance including in the Unregulated Energy element of the LETI EUI methodology do not Fairly and reasonably relate to the development permitted in many cases, as these are not in a legal sense Fixtures of the property but the occupiers Fittings, and in many cases portable appliances.
When developing a commercial building occupiers fittings and their specific energy consumption is not generally considered as in most cases the exact specification of the fittings the occupier will install are not known, this is particularly true in speculative development where the occupier may not be known at the time of the planning application.
In speculative development circumstances reasonable assumptions would have to be used as we have illustrated in our explanation of why this policy requirement is ineffective these can be varied considerably by changing reasonable assumptions to a material degree without altering the proposals in a manner that would conventionally be regarded as a change to the development or to be permanent fixtures of the development. - It is logical to conclude that if changes not constituting a change to any permanent part of the development can change the acceptability of a development in the terms of the proposed policy, that the policy includes regulations applying to things not fairly and reasonably relate to the development permitted, by its inclusion of Unregulated Energy use in the planning consideration.
Turning to the final limb of the Newbury Criteria, reasonableness, we would suggest that the incorporation of Unregulated Energy use in the planning consideration is unreasonable. There is a considerable disparity between the time it takes to deliver and fully let a commercial property which will typically take several years from planning to first occupation and the product cycle of plug-in appliances such as computers and IT equipment with technology in such devices advancing roughly every 6 months. In our view, incorporating energy use based on devices available at the time a planning application is made would be a largely theoretical exercise as by the time a property is built a new generation of devises will be on the market. Any attempt to bind occupiers to the suggested specifications devised at the planning stage would unreasonably impose a requirement that would oblige occupiers to forego the economic and environmental advantages of fitting out a building to the latest specification.
We consider the requirements this would create to be counter intuitive as fitting out to the latest standards in areas such as IT and security equipment generally results in longer fit out lifespan, reducing whole life carbon emissions by extending the interval until the building requires its first refurbishment.
Control via the planning system over details as trivial as what devices can be plugged into the building, would also be unreasonable on the basis that it would represent an unreasonable level of public intervention in the use of private property. Such controls and present potential issues from a Human Rights perspective as they could be argued to interfere unreasonably with peaceful enjoyment of property.
In short, the lawfulness of this policy requirement comes down to whether it is lawful for ‘Unregulated Energy’ use such as that from plug in devices to the regulated by the planning system. We take the position that while consideration of typical energy use would be a lawful material consideration that could be regulated by the planning system, that the devices that will be plugged into development’s electrical sockets after it has been completed cannot lawfully be considered as part of any standard used for assessment of planning applications, as there is no reasonable basis for considering an item temporarily plugged into a building to meaningfully be a permanent fixture of that building.
As a simple analogy of our argument, we are suggesting that as the act of plugging a laptop into a plug socket within a building does not make it part of a building, and therefore when evaluating the performance of the building the make and model of the laptop that might be plugged into it at a later date, should reasonably not have any bearing on how the building is considered to perform and whether or not it should be given planning permission.
Summary
The problem with the LETI EUI approach in application at the planning stage and within the legal limits of what the planning system is intended to regulate is that it is by design an approach that does not adopt industry-wide “average” profiles for Unregulated Loads such as plug in portable appliances. As such by design the LETI EUI intended to provide a highly accurate EUI measure approach incorporates Unregulated Energy use, including plug in appliances, that are outside the scope of what is reasonable for the planning system to regulate.
Our position comes down to a consideration of the proper legal limitations upon what a local planning policy should opine upon and reasonably consider as a material consideration as they are not a fixed part of the development. When legal tests such as The Newbury Criteria derived from Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment [1981] are applied, we would suggest the policy falls short as it draws into consideration matters that are clearly not part of the development, but rather part of the subsequent lawful activities an end user may wish to carry out inside the scope of any permitted use.
If considering the use of EUI calculated on this basis we would suggest it is important to consider the following questions;
1) Why portable electronic devices would be considered to materially be part of a development? - We would suggest that portable electronics fall outside the scope of what can reasonably be considered materially part of the development as they are not part of the building and are portable by nature.
2) Is it reasonable to expect a speculative commercial developer to be able to predict exactly what portable electric devices their end tenants use? – we would suggest that with development and lettings periods extending into several years that there will have been multiple release cycles for portable electric devices like phones and computers between the submission of a planning application and completion of a development, and as such many tenants may choose equipment that has not even been announced by manufactures at the time planning applications are submitted. – as such detailed specifications assumed at a design stage offer little if any accuracy advantage over standardised approaches, at the expense of significantly reducing their reliability as a means of comparing building performance.
3) Would the standardised approach incorporated into national policy by Written Ministerial Statement in December 2023, better provide for consistent and predicable planning decisions in line with national policy requirements? – we would suggest that a standardised approach that applies standard averages for end user consumptions and uses the methods specified in national policy allows for a more consistent assessment of the performance of the development, whist remaining within the reasonable scope of planning regulations.
4) Is the LETI EUI approach reflective of typical building use or user specific? - we would suggest that the LETI EUI approach reflects not the typical performance of a building but the initial performance under an estimation of the first occupiers use. As the LETI EUI approach incorporates plug in portable appliances that will change with occupier and equipment changes throughout the building lifespan. Any additional accuracy gained in reflection of the specific user can only really be said to hold validity for at most 3-5 years, after which point equipment will likely change even if the same occupier is present.
5) Is an approach that by design introduces “margins and caution on every variable” a justified approach or one that is likely to go beyond actual need? - we would suggest that in every instance where policy goes beyond what is necessary, there is an inefficiency in policy that results in an opportunity cost as such would suggest that any additional margins should be properly justified and considered before being considered to be sound assumptions in policy terms.
In the case of the LETI EUI application proposed, the technical requirement for net zero is based on energy consumption and no credit is given for renewable generation. We would question if this an efficient and effective policy in terms of reducing emissions, as clearly renewable energy production is an alternate option to deliver a net zero building. – for example, to illustrate this alternative, the typical factory use EUI is currently around 96 kWh/m2/year and modern solar panel that are commercially available can deliver around 284 kWh per sqm per year based on a 20% efficiency in Bexhill meaning that an industrial building with less than 35% of its roof covered in unshaded solar panels could achieve zero energy consumption at the meter.
Having considered these points we would suggest that the standard applied in the draft policy is unsound as it is not justified by a current evidence base, does not follow the approach mandated by national policy, is infective due to vagaries of the proposed measurement standard, and is unlawful as it attempts to consider matters beyond the reasonable scope of the planning system.
Attachments:
- Objection to Policy GTC1 (196.88 KB)
Object
Rother Local Plan 2025-2042 Regulation 19 (pre-submission) version September 2026
Policy BX45: Plot 7, Bexhill Enterprise Park, Mount View Street
Representation ID: 31752
Received: 13/11/2026
Respondent: Sea Change Sussex
Legally compliant? No
Sound? No
Please see full objection to BX45 in attached response form.
The restriction of Plot 7 to Use Classes E(g), B2 and B8 limits flexibility to respond to future retail and leisure needs, regeneration opportunities and economic growth. The evidence underpinning retail capacity forecasts does not adequately reflect future changes in expenditure patterns, tourism and investment potential. The requirement to provide parking for Combe Valley Countryside Park lacks a clear planning justification and is not directly related to the impacts of the proposed development. The requirement for a 15-metre habitat buffer applies a fixed setback irrespective of site-specific ecological circumstances and does not reflect a proportionate, evidence-led approach to habitat protection and mitigation. Alternative approaches are sought in relation to land uses, visitor parking provision and ecological buffering.
Change to proposed use classes
SCS’s Advocated Alternate Approach
One of the central aims of planning policy nationally is to create conditions in which businesses can invest. Section E1, within the August 2026 NPPF creates strong support on a national level for economic policy that is sufficiently flexible to respond to future demand.
In the case of Bexhill, we would suggest that there is significant evidence to support the argument that the town is an opportunity area for growth. These include recent investments in the town including;
• The creation of the Bexhill – Hastings Link Road
• The North Bexhill Access Road
• The North East Bexhill Gateway Road
• Combe Valley Hospital
• Bexhill Enterprise Park
• The Gateway Housing Developments
Proposed future investments including;
• £19.537 million Pride in Place funding;
• implementation of the Bexhill Place Plan;
• station connectivity improvements;
• public realm enhancements;
• enhanced visitor attractions;
• De La Warr Pavilion improvements;
• programmes to reduce vacancy.
Our belief is that these point to the town holding notable advantages when compared to a typical settlement across the country. This creates a strong case for the local plan to incorporate additional flexibility for growth within the town as these are factors that sit outside the scope of typical modelling norms.
The alternative approach we would suggest is that policy should take a more ambitious approach that provides not simply for baseline need but plans for the success of the hundreds of millions that have been invested in supporting the town’s growth.
In planning for success, it is necessary for the town’s planning policies to provide clear routes for drivers of significant growth such as significant new retail and leisure anchors that will expand the towns draw as a destination to be delivered in accordance with local plan policy.
As the town centre is constrained, many of the Anchor facilities that the retail assessment notes are not present in the town cannot realistically be delivered within the town centre. We would therefore recommend that subject to the normal tests required by national policy that they may potentially be located on Plot 7 Bexhill Enterprise Park, given its accessibility to the town centre by public transport and ability through wider transport links to draw additional trade to the town.
Requirement to provide parking for the Countryside Park
Alternative policy suggestion
We would suggest that this is a policy that seeks to deliver an area wide public benefit that cannot be said to fairly and reasonably be related to this development alone, with the beneficiaries of the park being spread across not just the wider Rother District Council area but also delivering benefits to the people of Hastings.
There is ample accessible land within public ownership, that could provide an alternative location for the countryside park to meet its own parking needs, mitigating the adverse impacts of its trip generation on the surrounding area caused by use of the park.
We would suggest that a more sound policy approach to resolving the parking issues that the policy asserts a lack of parking for the park causes, would be to allow the creation of a public car park on part of the neighbouring publicly owned land, and utilise CIL contributions or funds held by the Combe Valley Countryside Park Community Interest Company to fund this provision, considering it can appropriately be classified as greenspace infrastructure provided for the benefit of the town as a whole.
15m Habitat Buffers
Alternative policy suggestion
We would suggest that an appropriate buffer should be determined based on ecology surveys of the site as part of considerations at the application stage.
Objection to Policy BX45 (please see attached response)
Change to proposed use classes
We note that policy has shifted marginally away from consideration of retail use and would question the need to tighten the policy wording to the specified use classes and subclasses.
We recognise that the approach taking by RDC has been to rely upon the advice of external consultant in this matter, and while we recognise that RDC took our comments on this matter seriously and that their consultant responded to a number of the points made directly. Having reviewed the updates to the retail impact assessment we consider the council’s consultants to have dismissed several points without due consideration of their impacts and the overall approach to adopt several conservative assumptions in terms of retail provision need.
We believe that these result in an underestimation of retail need and potentially sacrifice opportunities for the town in doing so.
We would suggest that the limitation of this site to use class E(g), B2 or B8 is unsound for lack of adequate justification due to issues within the Retail Assessment detailed below. – These primarily in our view come down to an approach advised by LSH on retail policy, that is overly pessimistic and does not allow succinct flexibility in its suggested policy to allow for any significant improvements that may come for any of the numerous regeneration efforts that are underway in the town.
Underestimation of cross shopping impact
In terms of retail impact, we note that at 271 LSH suggest that a Leisure and retail development at Mount View Street is less likely to generate cross shopping with the town centre than the existing out of town provision at Ravenside Retail Park. We would suggest that this is assertion is poorly considered as there are no indicators to suggest that cross shopping would be less likely.
Contrary to this assertion connectivity by car and public transport to the town centre retail area is similar between the sites with both benefitting from direct bus routes to Bexhill Station, and only 0.1miles difference in journey distance by road, indicating that there would be minimal difference in accessibility. Further to this we would highlight that a cross shop may be more likely by public transport as the bus route serving Mount view street runs to the Conquest Hospital which is not a competing retail major destination limiting alternate cross shop destinations.
By contrast the 99-bus route serving Ravenside Retail Park links to competing retail offerings at Hastings Town Centre, St Leonards, Bexhill Road Retail Park, Bulverhythe Retail Park, Little Common, Pevensey Bay, Sovereign Harbour, and Eastbourne Town Centre, which can be viewed as a route that holds considerably more potential for town centre spend leakage to alternate destinations than the routes serving Mount View Street.
We would also highlight that Ravenside Retail Park has a store mix that is heavy on uses where cross shop potential is limited with over 170,000 sqft occupied by stores offering groceries, DIY Materials, Auto Repair, large home furnishings, and pharmacy goods. These are all common low cross-shop store types, where customers typically visit for a single, specific purpose and rarely combine the trip with visits to neighbouring stores in the same centre or the high street, which likely reduces cross shop potential.
Our assertion based on these observations is that there is no reason to expect that cross shopping with the town centre would be materially worse than at Ravenside Retail Park. Contrary to this we would suggest that a retail park on Mountview street would likely perform better in terms of cross shops as the public transport routes serving Ravenside Retail Park take passengers to a range competing destinations outside the town centre, whereas the route serving mount view street primarily links to residential areas and health facilities.
Underestimation of Population Displacement Impacts
At 269 and 270 of the LSH update the impacts of population displacement as a result of new housing are dismissed, without certainty over whether the housing numbers have been increased since the figures used within the study were produced.
While we accept that housing number are one of several factors our estimate of the discrepancy at the regulation 18 stage placed estimated differences between the figures used and the population increase if houses planned were occupied at over 3,150 additional residents not provided for over the plan period.
It is reasonable and justified to call into question the robustness of an evidence base that admits, as the LSH report does, that it is forecasting a need using population as an input with uncertainty over the accuracy of the figure utilised. In terms of input accuracy error this could account for over 7% of the town’s current population, which in our opinion is unlikely to be insignificant.
Failure to account for pace of delivery on new homes and development
The assumption made on the impact of these allocations is that they will emerge towards the end of the local plan period, we would however question this as many of the proposed new homes are on sites with planning permission, resolution to grant planning permission, or already under construction.
While the pace of delivery has been constrained in several cases whilst infrastructure works have been ongoing, which has affected delivery across the previous plan period, considerable progress has been made on infrastructure in this area. This will result in development being considerably faster over the coming years and a sizable portion of housing being delivered early in the plan period.
LSH at 269 of their report comment that this population increase is “unlikely to translate into a meaningful impact on retail capacity and is likely to relate to longer-term projections beyond ten years.” We would however suggest that housing that has advanced to its current stage is likely to start to impact within the first few years of the plan period.
Unjustified and Unduly Pessimistic assumptions on Market Share
The updated retail assessments model remains fundamentally based on market share assumptions that are assumed to have remained constant from 2022, stating at 176 that “It is assumed that market shares have remained constant since the 2022 household survey was conducted.”
We would suggest that this assumption is difficult to defend given the scale of changes in the retail market since 2022, which are set out in some detail within our regulation 18 representations (attached).
In addition to this the retail assessment assumes no improvement in expenditure retention over time despite recognising existing retail spend leakage to Hastings, St Leonards, and Eastbourne and extensive planned investment in Bexhill. Given the sensitivity of retail impact assessments to leakage even a modest improvement in spend retention will have significant impact on retail need.
In our view there are actions underway that should help support the town to improve its retail spend retention these include.
• £19.537 million Pride in Place funding;
• implementation of the Bexhill Place Plan;
• station connectivity improvements;
• public realm enhancements;
• enhanced visitor attractions;
• De La Warr Pavilion improvements;
• programmes to reduce vacancy.
In addition to we would highlight that there is recognised throughout the retail impact assessment a lack of anchors to the towns retail and leisure offering, that help draw shoppers to the area from a wider regional catchment.
There are past examples within Bexhill where retailers have been allowed to grow to a size that can serve a larger catchment and this has resulted in significant retail sales growth for instance previously Marks & Spencer relocated from an ‘ageing town-centre site’ to a 46,000 sq ft shop in Ravenside Retail Park in Bexhill, East Sussex – resulting in sales growing by 103% year on year in December 2022.
We would suggest that the Retail Assessment in this regard, unduly pessimistic in its assumptions about the town’s performance and the scope for the town to attract investment from retailers willing to create stores and facilities that will act as major anchors for the Town and increase its likely proportion of market share.
In our view, the policy approach advocated by LSH in this regard similarly follows a pessimistic outlook, with limited provision being made for new investment beyond planned regeneration activities, despite their stated potential to clawback expenditure lost outside the district.
We would suggest that a restrictive policy approach that limits potential for new anchors to be created within the towns retail and leisure offerings is not justified adequately by this evidence. LSH’s recommendations rely heavily on the unevidenced assumptions that the regeneration will have no impact on Market Share and that the town will not have the opportunity for follow-on investment from the private sector to deliver anchors that pull additional trade into the town.
We would contend that both assumptions are unlikely based on active market interest, and our experience in the regeneration sector, and would suggest that a more flexible approach that allows the town the flexibility to invest, expand and adapt in a way that reflects the opportunities that may arise to address some of the weaker aspects of the towns retail offering would be a more appropriate approach.
We would draw comparisons in this regard to the guidance provided in Paragraph 2 of Section E1, within the August 2026 NPPF, in suggesting that given changing commercial property requirements, development plans should not be overly prescriptive about the types of uses or unit sizes that would be acceptable on particular sites. In our suggestion that commercial uses offering opportunity for growth should not be discouraged by policy.
Cumulative Impact of pessimistic assumptions on growth
In our opinion the LSH report update consistently adopts pessimistic assumption on growth and takes an approach of planning for limited growth potential. In short by selecting conservative assumptions and making limited allowances for success in other policy areas, the retail assessment provides a forecast of need that is predicated on multiple economic interventions in the town having little to no impact.
The result of the approach that has been taken to modelling is that the retail need estimates provide a baseline, that effectively represents a conservative estimate of retail market performance likely to occur without interventions or substantial changes addressing any of the underlying issues within the town’s retail market.
We consider the pessimistic success rate allowed for within LSH’s assumptions an unlikely outcome and would suggest that policy should plan for the capacity needed to support the success of the efforts being made across the town. In short, it represents a well justified baseline of what is required for the market to maintain pace or manage gradual decline, rather than reflecting what would be necessary for the town to experience significant growth.
Requirement to provide parking for the Countryside Park
We consider the requirement that the allocation "include provision to allow reasonable use of car and cycle parking spaces by visitors to Combe Valley Countryside Park" is unsound. We consider the policy requirement unjustified, inconsistent with national policy, ineffective, and to be legally non-compliant.
Why we consider the policy requirement unjustified
The policy is not justified because no proportionate evidence demonstrates a deficiency in countryside park parking or a causal link between such a deficiency and the development of this site. All trip generation to the countryside park is generated by the park itself, as such the park as a development would normally be expected to provide its own facilities.
We would also suggest that consideration of alternative options for provision within the area and within the park itself do not appear to have been given due consideration as an alternative.
The Park appears to have adequately accessible land in the immediate vicinity to support the delivery of its own parking facilities with over 66 acres of publicly owned land held by ESCC within and adjoining the park and cycleways through it sitting adjacent to the development sites.
We would therefore suggest that there is insufficient evidence to suggest that this is a necessary requirement for the acceptability of any employment use development on this site.
Why we consider the policy requirement inconsistent with national planning policy
It is inconsistent with national policy because it seeks to reserve development land for third-party parking demand unrelated to the impacts of the allocation and may encourage additional private car trips.
Why we consider the policy requirement ineffective
The requirement is not effective because "reasonable use" is imprecise, unenforceable and incapable of consistent application. Reasonable use leaves policy open to interpretation by officers who could legitimately reach varying conclusions regarding what constitutes reasonable use.
The policy clearly fails to specify the number of spaces, at what time they are to be available, who controls access, priority of use, provision for maintenance costs and business rates associated with spaces.
It also fails to outline how occupiers parking requirements would be impacted and protected and fails to establish if the landowner may charge for parking within this facility or not. All of which are necessary considerations impacting on the deliverability of development on this land.
Furthermore, we would highlight that this approach places the burden of providing for additional vehicle movements of an unknown quantum onto development sites that have already borne the burden of majority costs for the delivery of the road infrastructure accessing them.
Why we consider the policy requirement to be legally non-compliant
The provision of parking for the Countryside Park is in effect an unjustified developer contribution, that seeks the provision of works to mitigate the impact of an existing third-party development of a countryside park within this unconnected development.
We believe that there should be consideration of the reasonable ness of this in light of the legal framework and regulations that govern the use of conditions to secure such contributions.
We would highlight that Newbury District Council v Secretary of State for the Environment [1981] AC 578 the House of Lords established that planning requirements must:
• Serve a planning purpose;
• Fairly and reasonably relate to the development permitted; and
• Be reasonable
Similarly, Regulation 122(2) of the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010 states that .
“a planning obligation may only constitute a reason for granting planning permission for the development if the obligation is—
(a)necessary to make the development acceptable in planning terms;
(b)directly related to the development; and
(c)fairly and reasonably related in scale and kind to the development.”
Although both the Newbury judgment and CIL Regulation 122(2) relate to planning conditions, the underlying principles are relevant as although the draft policy may not expressly require a planning obligation, it effectively seeks the provision of a community infrastructure benefit for an existing public asset. The most common way to secure such provision would be by planning condition.
We therefore consider the key principle in this instance is whether there is a connection between the development of this site for employment uses and pre-existing countryside park parking demand. If no causal connection can be robustly established the policy effectively seeks a tariff that is unrelated to the effects of the development itself.
It is also necessary to consider if the requirement fairly and reasonably related to the development, and if it is otherwise reasonable. In this case we would highlight
• There is no causal link between development on this site and the pre-existing parking demand from users of the countryside park, meaning that the need is unrelated to development.
• There is no clear justification as to why park users should have priority over future occupiers or site users.
• There has been no consideration of the practical issues that potentially uncontrolled public parking on the development may have on deliverability
• There is no clear justification for policy requiring occupiers, landowners or developers of the allocation be required to subsidise parking demand generated by third-party visitors to an existing countryside park.
• There is no clear justification as to why suitable provision cannot be made within the Countryside Park, using funding from CIL payments and land already in public ownership.
We consider that the policy would require a legally unsound approach to securing the policy requirement upon grant of any planning permission as the requirement clearly fails to meet the tests established in Newbury and CIL Regulation 122(2).
Summary
In summary this is a policy requirement that appear to hold no direct relationship to the development included within the allocation, but rather to serve pre-existing park users that have not been provided for by the park.
We consider this an unsound approach as there is no sound justification or legal basis to place the burden of this obligation of meeting this third party need upon this unrelated development
15m Habitat Buffers
We would object to the inclusion of the requirement to “Include provision for the retention and future management of a buffer zone of semi natural habitat, at least 15 metres wide on the northern and eastern boundaries of the site, between the edge of development and the Priority Habitat, Local Wildlife Site and ancient woodland” on the basis that there is no evidential basis for the inclusion of such additional buffers within the site.
The site itself sits approximately 25m from the ancient woodland, and having recently been assessed through a preliminary ecological assessment contains no irreplaceable habitats, with most of the vegetation on the site boundaries being willow scrub and other vegetation that has regrown following historic site clearances.
While we recognise that were the site within 15m of ancient woodland this would be a suitable buffer to trigger further examination of the impact on mature trees, this site does not fall within that buffer zone, as such the proposed 15m buffer distance appears to be arbitrary.
While the intention to safeguard ecological assets is fully supported, the proposed blanket buffer is not justified by evidence, not aligned with national guidance, and risks undermining the effectiveness and deliverability of the Local Plan. A more proportionate, evidence-led approach is recommended.
Priority Habitats and non-statutory local wildlife sites vary substantially in their sensitivity to adjacent development. Research demonstrates that ecological disturbance thresholds depend on factors such as:
• species behaviour and ecology;
• habitat structure and condition;
• topography and screening;
• noise, lighting and hydrology.
Given this variability, a universal 15m buffer is ecologically arbitrary. For many Priority Habitats—such as Hedgerows, Traditional Orchards or Lowland Meadow—there is no established evidence indicating that a 15m separation distance is necessary to avoid adverse effects.
We would highlight that having reviewed the supporting evidence base for this draft local plan we can find no evidence to suggest such a buffer is necessary in these circumstances. The only references to this provision seem to be within the Habitat Regulations Assessment Screening which as would be expected concludes that having a buffer does not present an issue from a Habitat Regulations perspective.
In light of the lack of supporting evidence we would consider this policy requirement unsound as it has not been justified.
Attachments:
- Objection to Policy BX45 (187.48 KB)